Sacking senior executives poses legal minefield for companies

Feel like you senior executives are not performing? Or maybe you are on a board and want to kick off the CEO. But beware.

Feel like you senior executives are not performing? Or maybe you are on a board and want to kick off the CEO. Beware before you act.

Senior executives who believe they have been sacked unfairly are putting up a legal challenge on the way out the door.

According to Harmers Workplace Lawyers, Australian courts are increasingly awarding compensation in favour of senior executives who claim their positions have been unfairly or unreasonably terminated.

Bronwyn Maynard, senior associate at Harmers, says companies need to be much more careful about how they terminate the employment of senior executives.

“Increasingly we are seeing senior executives who feel their positions have been unfairly terminated challenging these actions. This is especially the case when an executive believes his or her reputation has been tarnished by implication of non-performance or wrong-doing.

She says a number of recent decisions of Australian courts have recognised “implied terms” in employment contracts.

This includes the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, and found that the company’s actions have been in breach of those terms, she says.

Maynard says this increased reliance on, and recognition of, implied terms in termination claims means that companies need to be more aware of fair and reasonable processes when considering terminating the employment of senior C-suite executives.

She said companies needed to be aware of the areas in which senior executives, if aggrieved, have recourse. These include:

• Breach of contract – The executive may argue that their dismissal was contrary to the terms of their contract. To avoid such a claim, employers need to take care that they do not act contrary to the contract or applicable policies both in the lead up to the termination (such as performance management, misconduct investigations) and at the time of the dismissal of the executive. Employers need to be aware that the contract comprises not only its express terms but also a range of “implied” terms, such as the mutual duty to preserve the relationship of trust and confidence. This may also include workplace policies, which can be regarded as having contractual force.
• Discrimination/unlawful termination claim – This may arise when an employee, including a senior executive, has been dismissed for a reason protected by legislation such as race, sex, age or disability. To avoid such a claim, employers need to take care that the basis for the dismissal is not prohibited by legislation.
• Trade practices claim – Trade practices legislation prohibits employers from misleading or deceiving employees in relation to their working conditions when offering employment and during contract negotiations. For this reason, employers need to take particular care when making representations regarding job security or expected length of employment, or an employee’s entitlements.

The way to avoid litigation? Get the contract of employment right, including the provisions for termination. These provisions would generally address not only the notice of termination, but also other aspects of the notice period such as payment in lieu of notice, “garden leave” and assistance during the notice period, she says.

“The contract should also clearly define the circumstances of summary termination for serious misconduct, resignation as a director (so that the executive is obliged to immediately resign as a director if their employment is terminated), and termination payments and entitlements. Furthermore, it is also important to continually review and update employment contracts, especially when promoting an employee, or if conditions of employment and/or workplace policies change.

One great tip is to ask departing executives to sign a deed of release upon termination. In exchange for the release, the employer will need to provide a benefit that employees would not otherwise have received, such as an additional payment or a longer notice period.