Australia’s two-speed economy paints a sobering picture for small businesses

In the heart of Sydney’s financial district, the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) ticker flashes green, signalling another day of gains. Yet, just a few blocks away, a “For Lease” sign hangs in the window of what was once a thriving family-owned café. This stark contrast epitomises Australia’s current economic landscape paradox – a booming stock market while small business closures and cost of living reach record levels. Are we witnessing a tale of two economies, or is the truth more complex?

The ASX 200 has shown remarkable resilience with 77% growth since March 2020. This surge typically signals a robust economy, with investors confident in future growth prospects. 

However, beneath this veneer of prosperity, there’s a troubling reality that doesn’t indicate a boom at all. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) reports an alarming increase in small business insolvencies, reaching levels not seen since the global financial crisis. 

It raises an interesting question: How can we reconcile a thriving stock market with the growing struggles of Australian SMEs?

The Reserve Bank of Australia’s (RBA) monetary policy is at the heart of this economic contradiction. The RBA has implemented a series of interest rate hikes to combat inflation, bringing the cash rate to its highest level in over a decade. While it has aimed to cool an overheating economy, it has had consequences.

For large corporations and investors, higher interest rates signal economic stability and potentially lead to increased stock valuations. However, for small businesses and everyday Australians, these rate hikes translate to:

• Increased borrowing costs: Making it more challenging for businesses to access capital for growth or even day-to-day operations.
• Reduced consumer spending: As mortgage repayments rise, households tighten their belts, impacting local businesses.
• Higher operational costs: From rent to supplies, everything becomes more expensive.

The impact on small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) has been particularly severe. These businesses, often described as the backbone of the Australian economy, are facing unprecedented challenges. In many instances, they are still recovering from the financial hit they took during the pandemic. Sometimes, they find themselves the subject of debt recovery action from the ATO, which is more aggressively pursuing outstanding tax obligations. 

Recent government data paints a sobering picture:

Small business insolvencies have increased by over 150% per annum since we have had the pandemic. 

Retail spending has slowed significantly over the last 12 months, with CommBank Household Spending Insights (HSI) Index falling for June 2024 showing: “The annual Household Spending Index growth rate remains subdued at 3.9% for the year, with spending on essentials such as insurance (+8.8%), utilities (+6.8%) and transport (+5.7%) seeing the biggest jumps in the year to June, suggesting consumers are still dedicating a significant share of their wallet to essential items”. 

While still low by historical standards, the unemployment rate has begun to tick upwards (to 4.1% in June), particularly in sectors dominated by SMEs, making a rate cut less likely in the future. 

In response to these challenges, the Australian government has implemented a range of measures aimed at supporting small businesses and stimulating economic growth:

• Stimulus Package: Targeted financial support for families and businesses, such as energy rebates for households and companies, as well as affordable housing targets to stimulate the construction industry and alleviate housing and rental shortages. 
• Tax Reforms: The new tax rates came into effect in July, and the instant asset write-off has been extended again.

However, the effectiveness of these measures and whether they go far enough remain a topic of debate. So, is Australia’s economy in good shape or bad? The answer, like the economy itself, is complex.

As Australia navigates this period of economic uncertainty, it’s clear that a one-size-fits-all assessment of the economy is inadequate. The challenge for policymakers, businesses, and individuals alike is to find ways to bridge the gap between the two speeds of the economy.

Small business owners’ adaptability and resilience will be critical, as will seeking professional help and guidance early to mitigate insolvency risks. For investors and large corporations’ a deeper understanding of the broader economic landscape beyond stock market performance is crucial.

Ultimately, Australia’s economic health will depend on our ability to address the disparities highlighted by the current two-speed economy. As we move forward, one thing is clear: the story of Australia’s economy is far from simple. It’s a narrative of contrasts, challenges, and opportunities that defies straightforward categorisation as simply “good” or “bad”.

Never miss a story: sign up to SmartCompany’s free daily newsletter and find our best stories on LinkedIn.